Graduate
  1. Classical mechanics  1.1. Advanced Kinematics  1.1.1. Generalized coordinate systems  1.1.2. Parametric equations of motion  1.1.3. Non-inertial frames and fictitious forces  1.1.4. Covariant formulation of momentum  1.1.5. Action-angle variable  1.2. Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics  1.2.1. Principle of minimum action  1.2.2. Euler–Lagrange equations  1.2.3. Noether's theorem and conservation laws  1.2.4. Normalized Speed  1.2.5. Canonical conversion  1.2.6. Poisson bracket and Hamilton–Jacobi theory  1.2.7. Hamiltonian chaos and integrability  1.3. Rigid body mobility  1.3.1. Euler's equations of motion  1.3.2. Principal moments of inertia  1.3.3. Gyroscopic motion and precession  1.3.4. Inertia tensor  1.3.5. Stability of rotational speed  1.4. Nonlinear dynamics and chaos  1.4.1. Phase space and stability analysis  1.4.2. Poincaré sections and bifurcation theory  1.4.3. Strange Attractors and Fractals  1.4.4. Lyapunov exponent  1.4.5. KAM theorem and quasi-periodic motion
  2. Electromagnetism  2.1. Advanced Electrodynamics  2.1.1. Green's function and potential theory  2.1.2. Multipole expansion  2.1.3. Image charging method  2.1.4. Boundary conditions and uniqueness theorem  2.2. Electromagnetic wave propagation  2.2.1. Plane waves in dielectrics and conductors  2.2.2. Waveguides and cavity resonators  2.2.3. Radiation pressure and optical tweezers  2.2.4. Polarization and Jones calculus  2.3. Relativistic electrodynamics  2.3.1. Covariant formulation of electrodynamics  2.3.2. Lienard–Wiechert potentials  2.3.3. Synchrotron radiation and bremsstrahlung  2.3.4. Electromagnetic field tensor and Lorentz transformations  2.4. Plasma physics  2.4.1. Magnetohydrodynamics  2.4.2. Debye shielding and plasma oscillations  2.4.3. Alfvén waves and tokamak confinement  2.4.4. Plasma instabilities and turbulence
  3. Statistical mechanics and thermodynamics  3.1. Advanced Thermodynamics  3.1.1. Legendre transforms and thermodynamic potentials  3.1.2. Fluctuation–dissipation theorem  3.1.3. Onsager interpersonal relations  3.1.4. Critical events and phase transitions  3.2. Quantum statistical mechanics  3.2.1. Density Matrix and Ensemble Theory  3.2.2. Bose–Einstein condensates  3.2.3. Quantum phase transition  3.2.4. Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein statistics  3.2.5. Partition functions and grand canonical ensembles
  4. Quantum mechanics  4.1. Advanced wave mechanics  4.1.1. WKB approximation  4.1.2. Path integral formulation  4.1.3. Quantum harmonic oscillator and coherent states  4.2. Angular momentum and spin  4.2.1. Spherical Harmonics  4.2.2. Clebsch–Gordan coefficient  4.2.3. Wigner–Eckart theorem  4.2.4. Spin–orbit coupling  4.3. Quantum scattering theory  4.3.1. Born approximation  4.3.2. Partial wave analysis  4.3.3. Optical theorem  4.3.4. S-matrix theory  4.4. Quantum field theory  4.4.1. Second Quantization  4.4.2. Feynman diagrams and propagators  4.4.3. Renormalization theory  4.4.4. Gauge theory and Yang–Mills fields  4.4.5. Spontaneous symmetry breaking and the Higgs mechanism
  5. General relativity and cosmology  5.1. Tensor calculus and differential geometry  5.1.1. Einstein field equations  5.1.2. Schwarzschild and Kerr metrics  5.1.3. Geodesics and Christoffel symbols  5.2. Cosmology and the Universe  5.2.1. The FLRW metric and cosmic inflation  5.2.2. Dark energy and structure formation  5.2.3. Cosmic microwave background radiation
  6. Condensed matter physics  6.1. Band structure and transport theory  6.1.1. Block theorem and the Kronig–Penney model  6.1.2. Fermi surface topology  6.1.3. Quantum Hall Effect  6.2. Superconductivity  6.2.1. BCS theory and Cooper pairs  6.2.2. Meissner effect and flux quantization  6.2.3. The Josephson Effect and SQUIDs  6.3. Topological phases of matter  6.3.1. Topological Insulators  6.3.2. Majorana fermions in topological phases of matter
  7. Nuclear and Particle Physics  7.1. Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD)  7.1.1. Quark–gluon plasma  7.1.2. Asymptotic freedom  7.1.3. Confinement and hadronization  7.2. Beyond the Standard Model  7.2.1. Grand Unified Theories  7.2.2. Supersymmetry and extra dimensions  7.2.3. Neutrino oscillations

Graduate → Nuclear and Particle Physics → Beyond the Standard Model ↓


Grand Unified Theories


Grand Unified Theories (GUTs) are frameworks in physics that aim to describe electromagnetic, weak, and strong nuclear interactions under a single theoretical umbrella. The concept emerged in attempts to extend the Standard Model of particle physics. While the Standard Model explains many phenomena beautifully, it leaves some questions unanswered. The search for GUTs attempts to fill these gaps and bring more coherence to our understanding of fundamental forces other than gravity, which have been integrated into later theories such as quantum gravity.

Standard model

Before we dive into grand unified theories, let's take a look at the Standard Model. This model defines the electromagnetic, weak, and strong forces and classifies all known subatomic particles. It organizes these into fermions (such as quarks and leptons) and bosons (such as photons, W/Z bosons, and gluons) that mediate the forces.

Fermions: - Quarks: up, down, charm, strange, top, bottom - Leptons: electron, muon, tau, and their corresponding neutrinos Bosons: - Photon: mediates electromagnetic force - W and Z bosons: mediate weak force - Gluon: mediates strong force

Why are GUTs needed?

Despite the success of the standard model, it has several shortcomings:

  • This does not include gravity as described by general relativity.
  • It has many parameters (e.g. fifteen fermion masses, force interaction constants) that must be measured experimentally rather than predicted theoretically.
  • Despite explaining the three forces, it treats them as separate rather than inherently linked.

Grand unified theories promise to address these issues by unifying different forces into a single force and reducing the number of fundamental parameters. Ideally, this would not only fit within a more aesthetic theoretical framework, but would also potentially show that all forces are manifestations of a single underlying force.

The math behind GUTs

At the core of GUTs is the idea of merging gauge symmetries. This involves group theory, which focuses on how different symmetries are represented mathematically. The electroweak theory, which is part of the Standard Model, successfully unified the electromagnetic and weak forces using SU(2) × U(1) symmetry group. GUTs take this idea further, aiming to unify these forces with the strong force. Popular candidate groups for GUTs include:

  • SU(5): an early attempt at unification presented by Georgi and Glashow
  • SO(10): a higher symmetry, representing an extension of SU(5)
  • E6, E8: even more complex extensions

Example: SU(5) model

SU(5) model was one of the first attempts at a grand unified theory. This model states that at extremely high energy levels (far higher than any currently achieved in laboratories), the electromagnetic, weak, and strong forces merge into one. Here's how it attempts to classify particles:

Particles in SU(5) group theory: - Quarks and Leptons fit into 5- and 10-dimensional representations. - Gauge bosons of SU(5) unify into a single set of gauge fields.

Implications and predictions

One fascinating prediction of GUTs, particularly notable in the SU(5) model, is proton decay. While the Standard Model assumes that protons are stable, GUTs suggest that protons can decay into lighter particles on very long timescales, a process that has not yet been observed experimentally. This is an important test for GUTs; failure to detect such decays remains a significant challenge for these theories.

Example of Proton Decay

In the GUT model, a proton can decay as follows:

p → e + + π 0

This specific decay mode suggests the breaking of a proton into a positron and a neutral pion. Experiments testing proton decay are ongoing globally, although no conclusive evidence has yet been found.

Current research and development

Despite significant theoretical advances, GUTs remain unproven. Major experiments conducted at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) continue to test various predictions made by these theories. Advances in theoretical physics, such as the unification of supersymmetry (SUSY), also offer promising avenues for the development and refinement of GUTs. Supersymmetry proposes a connection between fermions and bosons, potentially leading to more symmetric and unified models.

Visual representation

It can be complicated to understand how particles and forces are related, so let's use a visual representation to understand this.

Imagine the three forces as branches of a tree with their roots deep in the ground, invisibly but naturally connected:

Unified Force

In this diagram, the yellow circle represents a unified force at very high energy levels. The branches represent three forces (in different colors), showing how they appear separately at lower energies.

Challenges and criticisms

The primary challenge for grand unified theories remains experimental verification. Despite being theoretically compelling, no GUT has been confirmed experimentally. Critics point to their mathematical complexity and lack of empirical data as significant obstacles. Proton decay, a hallmark experimental prediction, has not been observed. Furthermore, the energy scale at which these theories predict unification far exceeds current technological capabilities, making direct testing impossible in the near future.

Critics also highlight the proliferation of new assumptions and parameters in some GUT models, which are similar to the very parameterizations they were intended to underpin from the Standard Model. Theoretical models such as E8 are mathematically esoteric and difficult to test experimentally, which can be a criticism of theoretical physics moving into areas beyond immediate empirical investigation.

The future of GUTs

Despite the challenges, the search for a grand unified theory remains a driving force in theoretical physics. New experiments, particularly those exploring supersymmetry and high-energy physics, continue to test these ideas. The integration of computational physics, advanced simulations, and even junior models of these complex theories into classrooms helps to improve understanding and guide future research.

Ultimately, as physics converges with other fields such as cosmology and quantum gravity (another great pursuit that attempts to reconcile gravity with the other forces), the understanding gained from GUT research could provide important insights.

Conclusion

Grand unified theories attempt to achieve a more profound symmetry in physics, a compelling idea of a single force from which all others arise. Though still theoretical, this quest impacts particle physics, cosmology, and beyond. This path is filled with challenges, but in facing them, physics attempts to answer some of the most intriguing questions about the universe.


Graduate → 7.2.1


U
username
0%
completed in Graduate

← Prev (7.2)
Beyond the Standard Model
Next (7.2.2) →
Supersymmetry and extra dimensions

Comments 



Grand Unified Theories

https://www.physicsflow.com/g/7.2.1?pfal=en